The Wilson A2000 Catcher's mitt is one of the best mitts I've ever caught with. At a comfortable 33 1/2 inches, it's the perfect size for maximum comfort and durability.
At the college level of play, a pro mitt is needed to be successful. The Wilson A2000 breaks in great, and will last. I've found that applying glove oil a few times a week in the pocket helps this mitt stay soft and keeps the leather treated.
I definitely recommend the Wilson A2000 Catcher's Mitt for a upper level catcher that wants a good solid mitt.
This particular mitt costs $150-$200